15 It Cosmetics Naturally Pretty Romantics Palette ($42; ulta.com)
Whatever she wants for herself, she makes a list and she buys it. While you appreciate her independence, paying attention to her wish list and surprising her with an item from it will definitely make her day. That means this 14-shade eye shadow palette with colors like “Devotion,” “Adore,” and “Romance” the perfect gift for any makeup lover (read: her).
